FTC Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This post (paid) links, which means I may receive a commission if you click a link and purchase something that was recommended. See full Disclosure and Disclaimer here.
Cosmetic ‘butters’ can be found in many skin care products nowadays. They are made from natural sources, such as beans, nuts, and seeds and provide moisturizing, nourishing and healing benefits. Right now, you may be wondering to yourself, ‘what are the best natural butters that will not clog pores?’
There are at least 10 different natural butters that are commonly used on the skin. The best ones do not clog pores and allow the skin to ‘breathe.’ These include almost all types, except cocoa butter, which is highly-comedogenic.
Now that you know the best natural body butters are those that won’t clog the pores, let’s take a closer look at this below. We’ll discuss each of the different butters individually and in detail. We’ll compare the two most common types (shea butter and cocoa butter) to see which is better for the skin. We’ll also include a recipe for a homemade, non-comedogenic version that is easy and affordable to make.
So, if you’re ready to learn all you need to know about natural body butters and which ones are best for your skin type, then please read onward.
What is the Comedogenic Scale?
The comedogenic scale ranks the likelihood of a natural oil (found in body butters, facial moisturizers, cosmetics, etc.) clogging pores in the skin. People who suffer from acne breakouts or blemishes should avoid highly-comedogenic oils, as they can aggravate and exasperate this problematic skin condition.
Those with drier skin types should choose oils somewhere around the middle of the scale, as they provide emollient-rich hydration with only a low to moderate chance of clogging the pores. The scale uses a numeric system from 0 to 5, like the one below:
- 0 – no chance of clogging pores
- 1 – very low chance of clogging pores
- 2 – moderately low chance of clogging pores
- 3 – moderate chance of clogging pores
- 4 – fairly high chance of clogging pores
- 5 – very high chance of clogging pores
What Natural Butter Is Best For Skin?
Since body butters don’t contain water, they have a thicker, richer consistency that locks moisture in the skin, keeping it soft and smooth for hours! There are at least 10 natural ‘butters’ known to work wonders on the skin! These include the following:
Shea butter is extracted from the nuts that grow on shea trees in West Africa. These nuts contain powerful antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties that heal and hydrate dry, sensitive or aging skin. Shea butter also helps treat chronic skin conditions such as eczema and psoriasis.
The University of Kansas did a study on treating eczema. They compared using Vaseline against shea butter. The shea butter treatment the skin was smoother.
Shea butter is also non-comedogenic (rated 0-1 on the comedogenic scale). It absorbs deeply into the skin, providing essential moisturization without clogging the pores. This makes it an ideal choice for those with acne- or blemish-prone skin or for people who want effective hydration that doesn’t leave the skin feely greasy.
Cocoa butter is obtained from whole cocoa beans, often used to make chocolate. It is sometimes referred to as a ‘healing miracle’ and contains a combination of powerful antioxidants and saturated fats that detoxify and moisturize skin.
Cocoa butter’s molecules are packed together very tightly, making it highly comedogenic (rated 4 on the comedogenic scale) and likely to clog pores. Therefore, it should not be used on oily or acneic skin types. It works well on excessively dry, chapped skin that needs extreme care and rich hydration. It is also great for diminishing the look of stretch marks, scars and age spots.
Mango butter is pressed from the seed or pit of the mango fruit. It contains high levels of essential fatty acids and is rich in vitamins A and C. It treats dryness associated with chronic skin conditions, such as eczema and psoriasis and helps reduces the look of fine lines and wrinkles on mature skin.
Mango butter is rated low on the comedogenic scale (ranked 1-2), making it a great choice for oily or acneic skin. It will not clog pores, allowing the skin to ‘breathe’ which increases its natural ability to heal itself. It also helps lighten, tighten and brighten the skin, reducing the appearance of dark spots, sun damage and stretch marks. Here is a study that was performed using it as skincare for feet.
Mowrah butter comes from the fruit of Madhuca longifolia tree in India. It is made from the seeds or kernels inside the fruit and contains linoleic, oleic, palmitic and stearic acid, which all aid in preventing premature aging of the skin. Here is a study that was published in 2015 on its functional characteristics and its nutritional value.
Mowrah butter is thought to be low on the comedogenic scale, meaning it is not likely to clog pores. Its rich antioxidant properties make it a wonderful moisturizer. It penetrates deep into the skin with ease, leaving a less-greasy feel compared to other body butters.
Kokum butter is derived from the seeds of the Garcinia indica tree, originating in India. It is one of the hardest butters, yet melts easily into the skin. It contains essential fatty acids, antioxidants and anti-inflammatory agents that work great on dry, sensitive and mature skin.
Unlike cocoa butter, kokum butter is non-comedogenic. It will not clog pores and promotes healthy skin cell growth. Its naturally-healing properties make it ideal for damaged skin while its emollient-rich ingredients soften and soothe dry skin.
Check out the selection of Kokum Butters at Amazon.
Babassu butter comes from the fruit of the Babassu tree native to Brazil. The palm is often referred to as the ‘Tree of Life’ because of its skin-friendly properties. The oil used to make this natural butter has anti-bacterial and anti-fungal agents that heal and treat acneic skin.
Babassu butter is rated 1 -2 on the comedogenic scale, which means there is a low to moderately low chance that it will clog pores. It helps relieve dryness, itching, and flaking associated with eczema and psoriasis. It is also rich in skin-nourishing vitamin E and essential fatty acids.
Olive butter is a rich, thick moisturizer that works wonders on severely dry skin. It is made by taking a shea butter base and adding olive oil to it as the ‘carrier.’ Unlike pure olive oil, olive butter is less greasy and absorbs deeply into the skin.
Olive butter is rated 2 on the comedogenic scale. This means there is a moderately low chance of it clogging the pores. It is rich in antioxidants and has been used for years in the Mediterranean as a natural anti-aging treatment.
Shop for Olive Butters at Amazon.
Almond butter is made from either raw or roasted almonds. Minimally-processed almond butter is naturally rich in vitamin E and essential fatty acids. It is used to treat inflammatory skin conditions (such as acne, eczema, psoriasis, and rosacea) and to hydrate dry skin.
Almond butter is rated 2 on the comedogenic scale, so there is a small chance of it clogging the pores. It is also safe to use on the face. All skin types can benefit from this natural butter, as it won’t clog pores or irritate the skin. Almond butter is especially good at treating rashes, burns and other skin ailments.
Hemp Seed Butter
Hemp seed butter is made from oil that is extracted from the seeds within the hemp plant. It has a smooth, creamy consistency with a mild, pleasant scent. It absorbs quickly and easily into the skin without leaving a greasy feeling behind.
Hemp has a 0 rating on the comedogenic scale, which means there is no chance of it clogging pores. This makes it an ideal choice for people with oily or acneic skin. Hemp seed butter is also safe to use on the face and helps reduce the look of fine lines and wrinkles on aging skin.
There is a good selection of Hemp Seed Butters at Amazon.
Peanut butter is made from raw or roasted peanuts. It is rich in vitamins C and E, which help to slow down the aging process in the skin. It also contains antioxidants that reduce fine line and wrinkles while the essential fatty acids work to keep skin smooth and your complexion bright.
Peanut butter is rated 2 on the comedogenic scale, so there is a low to moderate chance of it clogging pores. When applied to the face, it makes a great cleanser by removing dirt and debris trapped deep in the skin. It is also very good at hydrating dry skin.
Which Body Butter Is Best?
The best body butter is all-natural and non-comedogenic. There are many good ones to choose from online. Amazon has many non-comedogenic body butters to choose from.
Here is a list of a few below:
Sky Organic Shea Butter is a great one to try that is unrefined, pure and organic. It is made from raw ingredients that are cold-pressed and rich in vitamins and minerals. It is also easy to apply and can be used all over the body, including the face!
Palmer’s Cocoa Butter Formula Massage Lotion for Stretch Marks and Pregnancy Skin Care. This butter is free from mineral oil, parabens, and phthalates. It is also Dermatologist approved and hypoallergenic.
Plant Guru Almond Body Butter 100% Pure Raw Fresh Natural Cold Pressed. Skin, Hair, Nail Moisturizer
Best of all, these butters can be delivered right to your front door in as little as 2 days, so go online and check it out today! Trust me, your skin will thank you for it!
How Do I Make a Good Body Butter?
Making your own homemade body butter is easy, fun and affordable. For a great whipped version that is non-comedogenic, try the following recipe:
- ½ cup of shea butter
- ½ cup of mango butter
- ½ cup of grapeseed oil
- ½ cup of hempseed oil
- 10 – 20 drops of a non-comedogenic essential oil such as chamomile, frankincense, lavender, rosemary or sandalwood
- Gather the ingredients and pre-measure the correct amounts.
- Combine all ingredients (except the essential oil) in a double-boiler.
- Cook over medium heat until all ingredients are completely melted.
- Remove from heat and let the mixture cool slightly.
- Add essential oil to the mixture and stir well.
- Put the mixture in the fridge for about an hour.
- Use a hand mixture or blender and whip the cooled mixture until it reaches a fluffy, whipped consistency. Be sure to scrape the sides of the bowl with a spatula occasionally.
- Return the mixture to the fridge and allow it to sit for an additional 15 minutes.
- Apply liberally to all areas of the skin that require extra moisture.
- Store the remaining mixture in a glass jar with an air-tight lid in a cool, dry place. Keep it away from direct sunlight so the body butter doesn’t ‘melt’.
This is a wonderful, all-over body moisturizer that works great on all skin types. Best of all, the ingredients used in this recipe are all ranked low on the comedogenic scale and therefore not likely to clog pores. So go ahead and pamper yourself today, whip up this luxurious body butter and reap the beauty rewards that only all-natural skincare can provide!
Just a word of caution. Before applying oils or any homemade skin formulas, it is important to perform a patch test on your skin. Even if you have never had a prior history of any skin irritation issues you may find that concentrations and different mixtures may cause slight irritation like rashes, swelling, itching or even burning. To learn how to perform a patch test on your skin CLICK HERE
Which is Better Cocoa Butter or Shea Butter?
Cocoa butter and shea butter are considered to the best that nature has to offer when it comes to organic moisturizers. Each has been used for centuries to heal, soften and regenerate the skin and are commonly found in modern-day creams or lotions. However, there are significant differences between the two, which can affect your skin for the better (or the worse), depending on its condition and type.
While cocoa butter and shea butter do basically the same thing, which is soothing, soften and rejuvenate the skin, shea butter is thought to be better overall of moisturizing. As well, shea butter is less likely to clog pores, so it can be used on almost all skin types, including dry, combination, oily, acneic, sensitive and mature skin.
Conversely, cocoa butter is emollient-rich and works well on very dry skin. However, it is rated fairly high on the comedogenic scale and can clog pores. This can aggravate oily skin, causing it to break out. On the other hand, cocoa butter will help reduce the look of stretch marks, scars and wrinkles ‘better’ than shea butter on all types of skin.
Cocoa butter has a very pleasant, natural scent that is inviting and aromatic. Shea butter, in contrast, has a smell that is sometimes described as ‘stinky’ or off-putting. At the end, when it comes down to it, one variety isn’t necessarily ‘better’ than the other. It all depends upon your individual skin needs and your personal preferences.
Will Shea Butter Clog Pores?
Shea Butter is rated very low on the comedogenic scale (between 0 and 1), which means there is little to no chance that it will clog pores or irritate the skin. This is good news for acne suffers as well as those with chronic skin conditions, such as eczema and psoriasis. Look for shea butter as a key ingredient when you purchase your next jar of body butter.
Can Cocoa Butter Clog Pores?
Cocoa butter is ranked fairly high on the comedogenic scale (around 4), so there is a good chance it will clog pores. As a result, it is recommended that you use don’t use it on the face but rather on extremely dry areas of the body, such as feet, elbows or hands. Cocoa butter, if used sparingly or blended with other non-comedogenic butters such as shea or mango, may have a reduced risk of clogging pores.
In summation, there are at least 10 different natural butters that are used on the skin. The best ones are those that do not clog pores and allow the skin to ‘breathe.’ These include almost all types mentioned in this article, except for cocoa butter, which is rated high on the comedogenic scale.
So go ahead, treat yourself to some luxurious body butter today! It is the most effective way to deeply nourish and moisturize your skin. Just be sure to choose the one that is best suited for your specific skin type. It should also be all-natural, cold-pressed and (most importantly) non-comedogenic.